Menu

Whitefish Bay, WI Homes for Sale & Local Guide

Today, the Village of Whitefish Bay is a predominantly single-family residential community covering an area of 2.4 square miles, with a population of approximately 14,000 people. The Village is home to over 4,800 residential properties and over 100 commercial properties. Stately twentieth century homes stand alongside early farmhouses. The Village’s vibrant Silver Spring commercial district hosts an array of small businesses, a movie theater, and unusual shops.

Whitefish Bay, WI Homes By Price

$200,000 – $300,000
$300,000 – $400,000

$400,000 – $500,000
$500,000 – $600,000

$600,000 – $700,000
$700,000 – $800,000

$800,000 – $900,000
$900,000 – $1,000,000

Over $1,000,000
View All Homes

Explore Area Communities

Bay View Real Estate  | Bayside Real Estate | Brookfield Real Estate | Cedarburg Real Estate | Delafield Real Estate | Eastside & Third Ward Real Estate | Elm Grove Real Estate | Fox Point Real Estate | Franklin Real Estate | Germantown Real Estate | Glendale Real Estate | Grafton Real Estate | Greendale Real Estate | Greenfield Real Estate | Hartford Real Estate | Hartland Real Estate | Jackson Real Estate | Menomonee Falls Real Estate | Mequon Real Estate | Mukwonago Real Estate | Muskego Real Estate | New Berlin Real Estate | Oak Creek Real Estate | Oconomowoc Real Estate | Pewaukee Real Estate | Port Washington Real Estate | Richfield Real Estate | River Hills Real Estate | Shorewood Real Estate | Slinger Real Estate | Sussex Real Estate | Thiensville Real Estate | Waukesha Real Estate | Wauwatosa Real Estate | West Allis Real Estate | West Bend Real Estate | Whitefish Bay Real Estate

HOMES FOR SALE AREA OVERVIEW

Things To Do In Whitefish Bay

Canoeing & Kayaking
Outdoor Activities
Parks & Nature
Tours & History
Trails & Hiking

Available Homes for Sale in Whitefish Bay, WI

You will love this spacious 2 bedroom Whitefish Bay home! The first floor has a light filled living room, dining with direct access to the patio, and an updated kitchen. Upstairs you'll find a spacious primary bedroom with an extra deep closet, a second bedroom and an updated full bathroom. The lower level features a drop zone for all your things, as well as a rec room with new vinyl plank flooring. Relax outside on the cute patio overlooking the fenced in yard! Additional updates include fresh paint throughout, water heater (2019), custom blinds, and more! $299,900 Active

4781 N Hollywood Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

2 Beds 1 Baths 1,290 SqFt 0.110 Acres

This stylish 3BR, 1.5BA colonial is in an outstanding Whitefish Bay location! Highlights include a generous sized Living Room w/a newer picture window; Sun-drenched Kitchen w/granite countertops, custom cabinetry, and stainless appliances; Formal Dining Room; Three full-sized Bedrooms upstairs; The partially finished Lower Level would be the perfect Family Room, Home Office or Play Room. Large windows throughout the home allow for natural light. Gorgeous hardwood floors. Concrete patio with 6' privacy fence. 1.5 Car Garage w/additional driveway parking. Super close proximity to the middle school and high school...Amazing shopping, several restaurants, numerous parks and Lake Michigan are just a short stroll away. Truly a wonderful home in every way. Make your showing appointment today! $375,000 Active

1001 E Henry Clay St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,618 SqFt

Relocation makes this charming Whitefish Bay home available! Classic Colonial in a great location! First floor features newer windows, rich hardwood floors, built in china cabinets, and stunning fireplace surround with shelving. The white kitchen has stainless appliances and a butcher block counter with a view of the back yard, beautiful flower beds and 2.5 car garage. Lovely formal dining room and light-filled living room complete the first floor. Three bedrooms upstairs and a classic full bathroom. Enjoy the walkability to Silver Spring, Schools, Library, parks and more! Move Right In! $415,000 Active

5026 N Idlewild Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 1 Baths 1,390 SqFt 0.120 Acres

This quintessential dream home in WFB is a rare find that checks all the boxes! Enjoy the sprawling open concept DR/FR overlooking the back patio and large yard. The stunning gourmet kitchen remodel (2020), mudroom & walk-in pantry make life a breeze. All 5 large BRs have ensuite access (2 jack & jills & primary ensuite) + 2nd floor laundry. Newer 2.5 car garage + 1 car attached GAR (potential for a workshop, party garage or exercise space?) LL offers a finished rec room and oodles of storage space or to finish off. Newer roof & gutters (2020), several newer windows & HVAC. Walk to Big Bay (lake), schools, restaurants, playgrounds & the shops in WFB or SHO! $1,175,000 Active

4949 N Larkin St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

5 Beds 4 Baths 4,166 SqFt 0.240 Acres

Grand-sized center-entrance Colonial steps away from Schoolhouse Park & Whitefish Bay Library. Fantastic flow for entertaining thoughout entire 1st Floor. Living room w/ large beautiful windows and fireplace. Family room surrounded by great casement windows. Fabulous Dinette connects Living Room and Family Room to the updated white Kitchen with quartz counters, six-burner range and stainless appliances. Charming Butlers Pantry connects Kitchen to large Dining Room with room comfortably for 12. Stair Hall leads upstairs to 4 great-sized bedrooms. Recently-renovated Master Bedroom includes spectacular dressing room and Carrara marble-appointed ensuite Master Bath. 2nd full bath recently renovated with great counter space. Lower recroom with second powder room and built-in theater screen. $874,900 Active

5347 N Idlewild Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,444 SqFt 0.130 Acres

This lovely Tudor is perched one of the most coveted streets in Whitefish Bay. Just a block from Lake Michigan and in the heart of the village, walkable to restaurants, schools, parks, the grocery store, coffee shops and many other stores. Classic architectural details include leaded glass windows, arched doorways, coved ceilings and hardwood floors. The flowing layout provides ideal entertaining spaces including a large family room overlooking the lush backyard. Don't miss it! $575,000 Active

824 E Lake Forest Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,300 SqFt 0.140 Acres

This tastefully-updated, charismatic 3 bed, 3 bath Colonial charmer nestled in heart of Whitefish Bay really packs a punch! Enter to discover free-flowing floor plan with hardwood floors throughout. Living room features natural fireplace and bay window. Kitchen boasts of granite slab countertops and backsplashes, high-end cabinetry, and newer stainless steel appls. Enormous family room showcases vaulted ceilings and direct access to back yard. 2nd floor includes primary en suite...meaning not 1, but 2 full baths on 2nd floor! Extra wide back yard complete with 2 patios and lots of green space. Don't overlook add'l full bath on 1st floor convenient for dog washing and home's close proximity to Lake Michigan, Klode Park, Silver Spring, St. Monica's, Richards Elementary, JCC, and Bayshore. $525,000 Active

6123 N Santa Monica Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,005 SqFt 0.160 Acres

Just steps away from Big Bay Park and Lake Michigan, you'll find a home that's been meticulously maintained and classically updated with a familiar feeling of quality, style and practicality throughout the home. Stunning Mediterranean architectural details throughout the home. Notice the carefully balanced floor plan that makes this house a home! Your eat-in kitchen awaits your next dinner party or cookout. You'll notice the home is easy for outdoor entertainment and a fenced yard that your pup will enjoy - not to mention walks along the lake! Huge windows and bright, gleaming rooms await you in this stunning masterpiece! Take the home in and enjoy all the aesthetics it has to offer! $679,900 Active

5075 N Cumberland Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 3,363 SqFt 0.110 Acres

Fabulous 4bedroom 2 bath Cape Cod! Step into this charmer and you'll feel right at home. Bright living room with beautiful crown mouldings and a NFP, gorgeous updated kitchen, dining room with BiCC, two spacious bedrooms, and a full bath. The primary bedroom space upstairs will be a cherished retreat. An additional bedroom and newly renovated bathroom round out the second floor. There's even more to discover with the refinished rec room and newer mechanicals. Come see it today! $525,000 Active

5006 N Santa Monica Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,146 SqFt 0.130 Acres

Welcome to the Cumberland Forest neighborhood! This exquisite stately granite home exudes architectural beauty, substantial living space, wonderful care & updates! Enter by way of grand marble foyer w/ large radius windows that take your breath away. Living rm has a granite NFP, leaded bay windows & an adjoining family rm. The kitchen calls for gatherings & opens to a dining rm w/ French doors. Adjacent is a lounge-great as a study, toy, or music rm w/ adjoining bath. Great versatility! A primary suite to knock your socks off w/ 2 walk-in closets & ensuite bath. 4 add'l bedrms are well sized, 2+ beautifully updated baths & laundry complete the 2nd flr. The LL has a NFP, billiards rm & ample storage! Top it off w/ a mudrm, att garage & add'l 2 car gar, lovely landscape & blue stone patio! $1,375,000 Active

1584 E Cumberland Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

5 Beds 6 Baths 5,197 SqFt 0.210 Acres

Whitefish Bay draws you in with this charming colonial on Santa Monica Blvd. Thoughtfully built in 1992, the kitchen boasts a pantry and an island breakfast bar. The primary suite has two walk-in closets and a beautiful full bath with walk-in shower. The first floor features a den or office and a gas fireplace in the Living Room. Beautiful wood floors throughout the first and second floor. Plenty of space in the lower level recreation room with a bar and bonus room for an office or exercise room. Summer will be here soon and you will be ready with the fenced in yard and deck. $699,000 Active

5026 N Santa Monica Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,506 SqFt 0.180 Acres

Prime location! This beautiful Mikkelson built home boasts 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, natural fireplace with a gas starter. Hardwood flooring throughout entire upper level and most of the main floor. Bookcases framing the fireplace.Newer furnace, AC, Windows, Water heater.Also a Cedar closet on upper level - full cement drive to detached 2 car garage. Brick patio front and back along with extra large backyard! Beautiful perennials! $525,000 Active

5720 N Santa Monica Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,355 SqFt 0.170 Acres

Magnificent views of Lake Michigan await you at this stunning, WFB home! The owners have taken meticulous care of this Italianate, Eschweiler designed estate. Upon entering you are wowed by the stunning foyer with high archways that look out over the lake. Grand dining room and sunken living room both have wonderful fireplaces and are perfect for entertaining with views all around. Kitchen boasts gorgeous cabinetry and opens to a wonderful family room that looks out over the lake and opens onto an outstanding deck for morning coffee as the sun rises. 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths plus a fantastic laundry greet you on the second floor. Striking basement, top of the line mechanicals, curated gardens, heated garage/coach house, and gracious archways make this a one of a kind opportunity! $2,850,000 Active

5400 N Lake Dr Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 5 Baths 5,080 SqFt 1.370 Acres

Gorgeous Cape Cod in covetted Cumberland Forest walkable to restaurants on Oakland and quick walk to lake. This renovated house has it all and almost everything is BRAND NEW. Open concept, white kitchen with quartz counters, amazing larg center island and gorgeous stainless steel appliances. New oak hardwood floors throughout. 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths upstairs both with carrara marble vanities upstairs, one is ensuite to Primary Bedroom. Large walk-in closet for Primary Bedroom. Finished rec room in basement with seperate finished laundry room. New PELLA windows throughout, new roof, new furnace, new ac, new electrical panel and exterior service, new high efficiency on demand water heater.Additional endless list of improvements upon request. $579,900 Active

4631 N Newhall St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,112 SqFt 0.110 Acres

A remarkable find in a coveted neighborhood, this stately Tudor Revival is full of character & classic details. From the grand LR with natural FP to the beautiful patio outside the KIT, perfect spots for entertaining or enjoying a quiet moment await. The 1st floor also features a gorgeous foyer, elegant DR, spacious KIT, sunny 3-season room & lovely den along with 1/2 bath. Upstairs find a primary suite offering a luxurious ensuite bath, 3 additional BRs with wood floors & a recently updated full hall bath. On the 3rd floor, find a BR & bath as well as spacious attic, full of possibilities. A rec room awaits downstairs as well as laundry & ample storage. Nestled on a tree-lined street, this historic gem is close to shops, restaurants, trails & Lake Michigan. Truly a special home! $899,900 Active

4709 N Cramer St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

5 Beds 4 Baths 3,883 SqFt 0.180 Acres

View All Listings