Menu

Whitefish Bay, WI Homes for Sale & Local Guide

Today, the Village of Whitefish Bay is a predominantly single-family residential community covering an area of 2.4 square miles, with a population of approximately 14,000 people. The Village is home to over 4,800 residential properties and over 100 commercial properties. Stately twentieth century homes stand alongside early farmhouses. The Village’s vibrant Silver Spring commercial district hosts an array of small businesses, a movie theater, and unusual shops.

Whitefish Bay, WI Homes By Price

$200,000 – $300,000
$300,000 – $400,000

$400,000 – $500,000
$500,000 – $600,000

$600,000 – $700,000
$700,000 – $800,000

$800,000 – $900,000
$900,000 – $1,000,000

Over $1,000,000
View All Homes

Explore Area Communities

Bay View Real Estate  | Bayside Real Estate | Brookfield Real Estate | Cedarburg Real Estate | Delafield Real Estate | Eastside & Third Ward Real Estate | Elm Grove Real Estate | Fox Point Real Estate | Franklin Real Estate | Germantown Real Estate | Glendale Real Estate | Grafton Real Estate | Greendale Real Estate | Greenfield Real Estate | Hartford Real Estate | Hartland Real Estate | Jackson Real Estate | Menomonee Falls Real Estate | Mequon Real Estate | Mukwonago Real Estate | Muskego Real Estate | New Berlin Real Estate | Oak Creek Real Estate | Oconomowoc Real Estate | Pewaukee Real Estate | Port Washington Real Estate | Richfield Real Estate | River Hills Real Estate | Shorewood Real Estate | Slinger Real Estate | Sussex Real Estate | Thiensville Real Estate | Waukesha Real Estate | Wauwatosa Real Estate | West Allis Real Estate | West Bend Real Estate | Whitefish Bay Real Estate

HOMES FOR SALE AREA OVERVIEW

Things To Do In Whitefish Bay

Canoeing & Kayaking
Outdoor Activities
Parks & Nature
Tours & History
Trails & Hiking

Available Homes for Sale in Whitefish Bay, WI

Beautiful arts + crafts bungalow offers a blend of vintage details with impressive updates. Features a gracious living room with NFP, sunny windows, and hardwood floors throughout. A modern kitchen features granite counters, lots of cabinets, as well as Subzero and Wolf appliances. The open plan includes a cozy banquette for casual dining and comfortable family room. The 1st floor includes a flexible BR/office and beautifully updated full BA with shower. Discover another completely renovated full BA and 3 more interesting BRs upstairs. The LL includes a large rec room, bright laundry, and lots of storage. The fully fenced yard - great as is, or easily converted into greenspace. Nestled in the heart of Whitefish Bay, you're close to the library, middle and high school, and so much more! ******** $699,900 Active

5227 N Idlewild Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,427 SqFt 0.120 Acres

Fabulous Move-In Ready Tudor in cherished Klode Park neighborhood, East of Lake Drive these properties rarely come up! Loaded with a strong list of improvements and renovations this will satisfy the most selective buyers! Remodeled Kitchen with new quartz counters, backsplash, and custom cherry cabinets is open to living room and dining room. Fully renovated two full baths with state of the art fixtures and gorgeous tile. Nice Open Concept floor plan has 3 bedrooms up with spacious second floor patio with peekaboo views of Lake Michigan. First floor has 4th bedroom or versatile office space with French door to new patio overlooking spacious backyard and 2.5 Car Garage. Lower Level has neat finished space with room to grow and tall ceilings making expansion easy. Exceptional curb appeal. ******** $699,900 Active

722 E Carlisle Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,674 SqFt 0.120 Acres

Quaint Home in a Beautiful WFB Neighborhood! Professional Photos Coming Soon! ******** $364,999 Active

4902 N Larkin St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 3 Baths 1,333 SqFt 0.080 Acres

Light, bright, and surprisingly spacious! This Whitefish Bay Cape Cod boasts an open layout and modern renovations throughout, including a fully updated kitchen with new appliances. Main level consists of a generous bedroom useful in many ways, remodeled full bathroom, refinished oak floors, and direct access from the kitchen to a newly poured concrete patio and freshly landscaped fenced-in yard. Upstairs, no space is wasted with two bedrooms and a full bath including a walk-in closet. Head downstairs to a split space offering a rec room and future den/office. Plenty of storage and limitless functionality throughout. Whitefish Bay living is made easy with this trendy and move-in-ready home. ******** $409,900 Active

119 E Henry Clay St Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,500 SqFt 0.120 Acres

Fabulous Whitefish Bay 3 bedroom colonial in desirable location. Large living room with natural fireplace opens to formal dining room with built-in china cabinets, both with hardwood flooring and crown molding. Nice sized bright kitchen with island and stainless steel appliances and hardwood flooring. You'll love the main level den or office that leads to the deck and backyard. Upstairs has 3 nice sized bedrooms, all with hardwood flooring, and a nice sized full bath. The finished lower level has a huge recreation room, extra room for office or possible bedroom and full bath. You'll also like the fenced yard with playset and 2 car garage. Great opportunity to be in Whitefish Bay. ******** $489,900 Active

5232 N Shoreland Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,091 SqFt 0.130 Acres

Cute, cozy, and full of potential. Wonderful home offers a great opportunity to create and design your way. Offers a large living room with natural fireplace, hardwood floors, and crown molding. A bonus first floor room makes for a sweet den or home office. Discover three bedrooms upstairs including a large primary bedroom. The lower level includes good space for a fun rec room. Have more ambitious plans? The yard is larger than it looks - providing a great opportunity to add on and expand. Nestled on a beautiful block of more expensive homes, you'll be close to Richards Elementary, the JCC, Klode Park, and the Bayshore Town Center. You're going to love letting your ideas come to life! ******** $369,900 Active

6100 N Kent Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,811 SqFt 0.150 Acres

First time available in nearly 40 years, charming lannon stone siding ranch with hardwood floors and good circular flow, eat-in kitchen, dining room featuring a mid-century modern built-in china cabinet. Home has lots of opportunities to make it the perfect home for you. Large 2.5 car garage with newer cement floor and drive. Upgraded electrical service to 100 amp and new AC in 2022. You can enjoy this generous corner lot, great location, conveniently located walking distance to schools, Oak Leaf Bike Trail, public transportation, Bayshore and Dairy Queen. ******** $225,000 Active

4798 N Elkhart Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

2 Beds 1 Baths 1,327 SqFt 0.140 Acres

Same great house at a great NEW PRICE! Renovated kitchen with shaker style cabinets, butcher block countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ceramic tile floor and backsplash. NEW WINDOWS THROUGHOUT! Immaculate 4 bedroom home in desirable Whitefish Bay! This one has it all - central air, 2 full baths, hardwood floors, new carpets, freshly painted interior, generous closet space, basement rec room, and large yard with mature plantings. Walk to shops, restaurants, parks & little league baseball. Make this move-in ready home in desirable Whitefish Bay home yours! ******** $359,700 Active

5952 N Lydell Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 2 Baths 1,638 SqFt 0.120 Acres

This charming Tudor in a prime Whitefish Bay location is sure to delight! Step through the french doors into this lovely home that boasts a spacious living room with a natural fireplace and doors to the outside. Natural light pours in through the many windows of the dining room with built-in china cabinets. Make your way through the kitchen and enjoy the bright dinette that overlooks the backyard. The upper level offers a large primary bedroom with ample closet space, the 2nd & 3rd bedrooms and a full bath. The attic includes a cedar closet. Don't miss the rec room in the lower level complete with a wet bar and an abundance of storage. Enjoy the backyard, garden and 2 car garage. Spectacular location in a wonderful community close to award-winning schools, parks, restaurants and shops. ******** $474,900 Active

5828 N Shoreland Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,732 SqFt 0.140 Acres

Amazing panoramic views of Lake Michigan await you in this 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home. Gorgeous formal living room and dining room featuring sweeping views of Lake Michigan. Family room with loft. Updated eat-in kitchen. Primary first floor bedroom with updated bathroom and walk-in closet. Charming study with plenty of storage. Laundry on main floor. Upstairs find another spacious bedroom with updated en-suite bathroom. 2 additional bedrooms featuring Jack and Jill bathroom. Finished rec room in basement. 2 car attached garage. Additional 2.5 car detached garage allows for ample parking/storage space. LARGE lot with amazing views. Welcome Home! ******** $1,925,000 Active

4870 N Lake Dr Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,521 SqFt 1.180 Acres

Welcome to life in the Bay! Tucked into the highly desirable Cumberland School District, this charming colonial awaits! Some lucky new homeowners will enjoy the timeless touches in this home from the built-ins to the HWF's along with fabulous upgrades throughout. Gorgeous new eat-in kitchen, partially finished LL with new full bath, his and hers wardrobe in the primary bedroom, and new furnace (2020) to name a few! Upstairs boasts 3 spacious bedrooms while the LL offers a rec room and separate office creating ample space for comfortable living throughout. Three seasons porch and fenced in yard offer great spaces to relax and entertain all year long! Convenient location close to schools, the Oak Leaf Trail, Bayshore and Oakland Ave. in Shorewood. Call to schedule your private tour today! ******** $450,000 Active

4714 N Diversey Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 1,399 SqFt 0.250 Acres

This Whitefish Bay Colonial is on an unbeatable block walkable to Silver Spring businesses, restaurants and parks. You'll love the classic architectural finishes including the gleaming hardwood floors, crown molding and original woodwork. First floor features oversized, light-filled living room with natural fireplace and built-ins, full bath and open dining room with storage and updated, eat-in kitchen. Upstairs has second full bath and 3 generously-sized bedrooms, one with a walk-out porch spanning the front of the home, and main bedroom with walk-in closet. Enjoy the extra living space in the finished lower level rec room and additional storage space. Private, fully fenced back yard is perfect for entertaining and relaxing. You'll definitely want to see this one before it's gone!! ******** $509,900 Active

5440 N Berkeley Blvd Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,004 SqFt 0.110 Acres

Beautiful 3 bedroom cape cod home w/attached 1 car garage. Remodeled Kitchen in 2016, as well as remodeled bathrooms and upstairs bedroom in 2018. This home also offers a ton of storage space between the large closets, basement storage room and the attic dry storage! Perfect location for bike enthusiasts as it is just across the street from the Oak Leaf trail and within walking distance of the beautiful Estabrook park which offers a Beer Garden, a Skate Park and Plenty of walking trails on the Milwaukee River. ******** $349,900 Active

4700 N Wilson Dr Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 3 Baths 1,900 SqFt 0.200 Acres

Beautifully, fully renovated cape cod in the heart of Whitefish Bay. From head to toe, this home is move in ready! Walk in and notice the attention to detail on every facet of the renovation. Natural hardwood runs throughout much of the main level, along with luxury vinyl plank in the gorgeous kitchen, which features quartz countertops, brand new cabinetry, tile backsplash and stainless steel appliances. Two well appointed bedrooms and remodeled bathroom complete the first floor. Upstairs find a master suite with lots of space. The basement has a full clean slate, ready for whatever the owner desires. The cute backyard features a patio and nice space for a family. Fully renovated and under three hundred thousand in Whitefish Bay, what more could you want? See it right away. $279,900 Active

1021 E Hampton Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

3 Beds 1 Baths 1,008 SqFt 0.200 Acres

New construction in Whitefish Bay ! All of the benefits of living in this historic village without the maintenance issues. Four generous bedrooms, three full, one half bath. Several bedrooms with walk-in closets. Dual zone HVAC systems, oversized water heater, new water/sewer lateral to highlight a few of the mechanical upgrades. Custom cabinetry throughout including large island in the open concept kitchen which adjoins the family room with gas fireplace. Fulgor appliance suite. Mudroom entry from the rear of the house. Second floor laundry. Office/Library with huge windows and wet bar on the first floor. Incredible finished lower level with 9' ceilings. Scheduled for completion 9/9/22. ******** $959,000 Active

4635 N Idlewild Ave Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,250 SqFt 0.130 Acres

View All Listings